The paper is acceptable for publication as it is. However, we encourage authors to carefully reviewing the feedback and suggestions provided by the Editor/ Reviewer to incorporate all necessary comments prior to the camera-ready submission.
Conditional acceptance means major updates required before resubmission. The paper has potential but requires updates before it is suitable for. The authors will receive detailed feedback that they will be able to utilize to update their article accordingly.
The paper is not suitable for publication and updates are too extensive to improve the manuscript. Future submissions of the paper will not be accepted. However, we encourage such authors to consider a new research topic for the consideration in future.
The committee will give you a very specific feedback and suggestions for the improvement, rather than just pointing you mistakes.
The comments will be given based on observable data/facts and not based on personal opinions.
Thoroughly evaluate the paper’s relevance and its contribution to the scientific community. And thoroughly access all aspects of the paper including the technicality, literature, relevance, methodology, result, conclusion and references.
Thoroughly check appropriateness of the methodology, the validity of the results and the adequacy of the data analysis.
The committee ensure that the research is ethical and well organized. The committee will highlight both strength and weakness of the research paper.